Consultations are available over video, in person and also over the phone the same day.
Skip to content

Imputation of Fraud Between Spouses

Published February 14, 2014 by Sasser Law Firm

If the benefits of bankruptcy are designed to flow to the “honest but unfortunate debtor”, what, then, of the dishonest debtor? We sometimes encounter creditors who believe that any breach of a contract is evidence of dishonesty on the debtor’s part, but bankruptcy courts take a much narrower view of dishonesty, requiring proof, essentially, that the debtor induced the creditor to extend credit to him on some kind of false pretense or without any intent to repay the debt. This is a hard standard for creditors to meet, but, until recently, there was a long-established rule that if one spouse committed the fraud, then the fraud was imputed to the innocent spouse. After 129 years, that rule appears to be eroding.

In the recent ruling in Haig v. Shart, it was held that imputing the fraud of one person to another was “hostile to the well accepted principle that Congress intended to enact bankruptcy law ‘by which the honest citizen may be relieved from the burden of hopeless insolvency.'” What this means, practically, is that in a discharge-ability action against a married couple, the liability of each spouse is determined according to each one’s individual knowledge and actions regarding the loan in question. A dishonest husband and a dishonest wife might exit their bankruptcy case having received disproportionate relief based on their pre-bankruptcy behavior.

Associations & Awards

  • Business North Carolina 2022 badge
  • Attorney at Law Magazine, Local Authority Award
  • 2019 Business North Carolina Legal Elite Badge
  • super lawyers logo
  • expertise logo
  • North Carolina Bar Association | Sasser Law Firm
  • Martindale-Hubbell award for high professional achievement at Sasser Law Firm
  • NC Bar Association Legal Specialization | Sasser Law Firm
  • Top Bankruptcy Attorney | Sasser Law Firm
  • American Bankruptcy Institute | Sasser Law Firm
  • National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys | Sasser Law Firm
  • American Board of Certification | Sasser Law Firm
Free Consultation (919) 319-7400

Visit our cary office today

Cary, NC Office